David de Gea: The people’s choice


Diplomatic and idiosyncratic, Anders Lindegaard has a lot to be liked for. He is popular enough amongst fans: he’ll remind you that he’s not at Manchester United to “pick his nose”, and that his career has developed in the way of a “fairytale”, that he’s got “calmfidence” and plenty of it, and that he’ll love to have even “one seat” named after him (in response to Sir Alex Ferguson’s very own stand and statue). But what’ll ultimately pull him down is that he’s not the most popular. And it’s not that he’s not good enough, it’s just that he’s not as good as …

The people want David de Gea.

Sir Alex Ferguson, September 2012: “I am happy alternating them. That’s the policy I am adopting and I am happy with that situation.”
Sir Alex Ferguson, November 2012: “I am not happy to rotate [the goalkeepers] all the time — I don’t think that creates consistency.”

People change their mind all the time. And there’s nothing wrong with it, largely. When Sir Alex first told of his desire to rotate his goalkeepers, and then went ahead and put it into practice, United fans hoped he would see the apparent danger of it all sooner. His recent decision to put this rotation on hold would have been welcomed but for one thing: he’s chosen the wrong number one. Or so the consensus believe.

What has swayed things in Lindegaard’s favour, other than De Gea’s fitness, is that, according to Ferguson, there is no “actual reason to leave Anders out in terms of form.” But it is easy to object to ‘form’. How important is form? And just how in-form is Lindegaard? The answer to the latter is not very — he’s played a handful of games, for one, and probably not near enough to either justify even his temporary security nor a starting place ahead of the superior De Gea. Additionally, the goalkeeper’s efforts in the four games he’s played since De Gea’s last (excluding the Reading visit because the manager’s comments preceded it; more of which, of course, later) are simply not noteworthy enough, except in the defeat suffered at Galatasaray, where Lindegaard showed himself to be confident and competent — a good number two, in other words. The other three looked like this: another 1-0 defeat, this time at Norwich and two comfortable wins over QPR and West Ham where Lindegaard only had to make a single save in each.

This is barely an indication of an in-form player but that’s not to act as criticism, though it might seem to some (some) that the real reason the Dane is playing is because he just happened to be the last one in goal when it was decided that there would be no more rotating. Which brings us on to the first question on the importance of (good) form; you generally play the one who is performing better, even if the other is held in higher regard. However, it isn’t one of those situations. Which then means that De Gea should start if both are available. And if we’re going by form this season, also just a handful as if happens, De Gea edges it on those he’s played.

“I am going with Anders at the moment because he has not let me down,” Ferguson would say a day before Saturday’s 4-3 win over Reading, tempting fate as if on purpose. Lindegaard looked troubled and barely touched the ball inside the first half hour — except for when he had to trudge back into the net and pick the ball up. Three times. He was not culpable for all, nor was he fully responsible for any particular goal if we were to consider what could have been contributed defensively. Still. “He’s in a position where he can collect the ball,” said a blunt Gary Neville on Monday Night Football, analysing Reading’s second and third that started from Nicky Shorey’s corners — Nicky Shorey! — and ended up in the back of the net. Neville pointed out how crucial it was for Lindegaard to “dominate the box”, mostly because it would reassure his team-mates that he had control.

There is a certain irony in Lindegaard failing at what has lazily been presented as his main selling point — that is, being able to do what his Spanish counterpart cannot. De Gea would have instead rushed out for at least one, if not both, and punched the ball to safety, shortly before being chided by a typically disgruntled co-commentator for not catching it.

Whether the rotation policy itself really affects goalkeepers could never be proved outright, but logic would suggest it doesn’t. “It keeps us both sharp,” Lindegaard told MUTV last year, on this precise subject. “It makes us both better.” Two immediate responses to that would be, well, he has to say that and, second, he would still prefer to be the indisputable number one. It also made sense to rotate back then. United had two new goalkeepers and both were settling in. Once that time had passed, a clear winner emerged. Post-Christmas, De Gea was near-flawless and had what was justifiably his.

All of this, you might suggest, is simply a fuss over nothing, and a fuss too soon. That may well be right, but this is a problem beyond what the manager might say, beyond who plays tomorrow, or next week or next month. United need to settle on one goalkeeper because, above whether rotating is a hindrance or quite the opposite, it is clear who their best goalkeeper is. And it isn’t Lindegaard; but, in his defence, and get this, the man who he’s up against is pretty damn good.


10 responses to “David de Gea: The people’s choice”

  1. Rotimi says :

    Both keepers show of diffidence is an indictment on the most experienced defender on the field in any particular match. That defender for most of our matches has been Rio. He should always instruct the keepers afresh prior to set-pieces and keep communicating throughout the match. A keeper is as good as his defenders so the defence should also take the blame for bad goalkeeping. In the main, I think DDG should have a consistent run of matches now before Fergie can choose his No1.

  2. Shaiba says :

    DDG should leave Man Utd because he is not the type of keeper who should be sitting on the sidelines.

  3. julius says :

    I see no reason why David will be benched. The manager needs to let the young man grown fast, so that he can be better for the crucial stage of the Champions League. For me David is 100 per cent better than Lindegaard.

    Ferguson should stop gambling.

  4. Mushazy says :

    David de Gea is much better than Anders everybody knows, Ferguson just has no reason for using Anders over De Gea after he conceded 3 goals against Reading. But he criticises De Gea for conceding 2 goals at fulham, because he doesn’t have much love for him.

  5. Samuel says :

    “And it’s not that he’s not good enough”, as a goalkeeper and goalkeeping coach I have to disagree. Irrespective of any comparison to De Gea, Lindegaard is simply not good enough. He’s had very little experience at the top level (less than 20 starts for United) and is still, even at 28, to make 100 first team appearances. I was as shocked as Schmeichel when we signed him. He talks a lot, and all power to him, but that’s all it is as his talent simply doesn’t back it up.

    Also can’t believe that more emphasis is not being placed on how the choice of keeper affects the team’s style of play. With De Gea we can play a higher line as he is able to sweep, and his ability to find players from long range kicks gets us (to borrow an NFL phrase) good field position/high up the pitch. Essentially his superior/quicker distribution enables us to counter quickly. Stats show that De Gea plays 20%+ of his passes long compared to Lindegaards, but has an almost identical pass completion. Lindegaard constantly rolls the ball to the center backs inviting oppostion pressure (I even noticed Rio/Evans having a go at him about this during the match, not to mention their reluctance to pass the ball back to him when under said pressure).

  6. Ismail N says :

    Lindergard is doing well. DDG lost his place when got injured. He must be patient and wait for his time.

  7. payhay1967 says :

    he didnt get injured, he had some teeth taken out

  8. Edy says :

    To : Sir Alex with all our respect for you.. I feel no one has been bigger than it’s Club especially for Man United.. But this time don’t let us down by you Sir Alex because mostly Manchester United Fans in the World wanna see David De Gea as our No. 1 Goalkeeper not become No. 2 (STOP ROTATING KEEPER)
    We all have faith in him, because we all believe he will become one of The Best Goalkeeper in The World or even can be best of the the best goalkeeper for Manchester United and Spain..
    If you don’t want to using him why should you spend a lot of cash for De Gea??
    Club never be a Huge Club if not because of Fans..
    don’t let us down because of you Sir..
    Can’t you see what we want as a FANS!!

  9. momodou bah says :

    de gea is better than lindergard…. he deserve the number 1 spot. fergie is not playing game between them.. lindergard is lazy in goal and he does not command defenders on the pitch. de gea is young and talented even man utd best keeper admired him… he is the best….i love him

Trackbacks / Pingbacks

  1. RoM Reads - December 8, 2012

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: