Manchester United are finding that corner kicks are delivering discouraging returns

Sir Alex was most likely joking when he claimed that Charlie Adam is worth £10million on his ‘corners alone’. That evening, however, he witnessed two fine deliveries from the Scottish midfielder – both from the corner flag, both found the net. It outlined United’s apparent frailties and inability to defend them and perhaps, most importantly of all, contrasted with their attempts at the set-piece, which has brought diminishing returns in past campaigns.

Take last season, for example. An astonishingly low 2.5% of all corners taken had found the net (a modest success rate of 1 goal every 40 corners – in total, 6 from 240). This year has seen a slight improvement; the success rate stands at just above 4% at the time of writing. But there is still more to uncover; goals do not tell the whole story. 47 attempts have come out of the 197 corners taken so far in this campaign, a percentage of 24% compared to that of last years which is slightly better at 27%. Statistics can sometimes be deceiving but what these figures do suggest is that a large chunk of corners materialise into nothing – just as many Manchester United fans have suspected.

However, that does not mean that blame should entirely rest on United’s players and their corner kick takers. That begs the question; does anyone really need to be blamed? Perhaps yes, to an extent. Some have grown frustrated at the sight of a cross not even beating the first man. It has happened on several occasions this season, but that only tells part of the story.

Manchester United have scored more headed goals (16) than any other team in the Premier League. What that might implicate is that United’s players seem to have no trouble, then, in the air. It is also acts as a compliment to United’s wide men who have obviously contributed to a large chunk of those headed goals. But, having scored so few from corner kick suggests that there is more to than just having players who thrive in the air or players who can deliver a good cross.

Tony Pulis once said without any conviction:  “I think people are now coming to realise that you can use set-pieces to your benefit. Especially the top clubs who have got more quality players – that means more quality free kicks and corners.”

It’s a logical argument. But an ultimately flawed one. Barcelona’s European-conquering side of 2008/09, easily one of the most gifted teams to ever play the game, did not find much success from corners despite having several players who were (and still are) renowned as being the masters of the pass. That year, they had a success rate in the Champions League of one goal out of 82 corners taken. Pulis’ argument should thus be deemed unfounded, shouldn’t it? Wealth of talent doesn’t always bring about ‘quality’ results.  That applies to United, too, and the man given the responsibility to deliver the cross – be it Ryan Giggs, Nani or anybody else. The notion that a player should be automatically able to find a good cross, one that eventually finds the back of the net because he is able to deliver a good ball in open play can only be dismissed as a limited argument. There are other factors that decide a good or bad corner, more of which we’ll find out later.

United and Barcelona are not alone in failure of the converting from a corner. In an article for Uefa’s magazine Champions, Paul Simpson and Sheridan Bird discuss the apparent ‘rise and fall’ of the set-piece, a point that was well-backed by statistics indicating that the success rate of the corner kick was indeed declining:

“On average, it took teams 54 corners to score a goal in the UEFA Champions League. Just 23 of 320 goals came from the set-piece. Andy Roxburgh, UEFA technical director, says: ‘The success rate from corners has declined by 46% in just three seasons in this competition.’”

Those dwindling numbers are perhaps a touch concerning. But if Roxburgh’s comments are anything to go by, it is not just Manchester United who have struggled to convert from the set-piece. It is a problem shared by many teams and there are many reasons as to why.  In some cases, teams might be susceptible to counter attacks and so might not commit many players forward especially if their opponents are a so-called bigger team. More crucial to understanding why numbers might be decreasing is that teams are believed to be spending more time in training preparing for them and defending them. And then, secondly, more often than not, the box is usually swamped with defenders. Rob Bagchi, of the Guardian, recognises this: “Usually it [corners] ends up as a simple equation of being outnumbered and unless an extraordinary cross or slackness opens up an avenue to score it becomes a routine defending exercise.”

Perhaps the signing of Adam (we wouldn’t recommend it, Fergie) wouldn’t see the disappearance of United’s corner curse – he might well be able to clear the first man, but what’s to say that he will find great success from it if teams continue crowd the penalty area?

The corner kick is still to be feared; goals will be scored, posts will be hit and crossbars rattled. But what we will find is that less and less, as the numbers suggest, will find the target. That has much to do with the opposition defending in numbers, and so all must not be put down to the fact that some do not beat the first defender. Nor should we conclude that United do not possess enough competent takers; that may well be true, but when good deliveries come about a successful result is not always assured. Fans mustn’t fret if a corner comes to nothing. Manchester United are a team who thrive when the game is flowing, and anything that comes about from a dead ball is a bonus. We must also recognise that United are not alone and that we are seeing a rapid decline in this particular set-piece.

Statistics of Manchester United’s successes (or failures) from the corner kick are courtesy of OPTA sports. Statistics of successful corners in Champions League courtesy of UEFA.


25 responses to “Manchester United are finding that corner kicks are delivering discouraging returns”

  1. Justin says :

    It’s amazed me all season, the amount of corners we’ve wasted. Personally I think it’s more to do with the delivery which far too often has been poor. With some of the players United have got I think our lack of goals from corners is inexcusable.

  2. Danny Salford Red says :

    Agree with Justin. I reckon 100% its the deliveries. For all his assists Nani can never seem to clear the first man and to be honest ive seen lots of evidence that this is also creeping into Giggsys game a bit. When valencias been back a bit and in top form I would expect us to become more dangerous from corners.

  3. The Gaffer says :

    It’s a valid point, that – but as the statisitic mentioned in the blog about Barca in 08/09 (“they had a success rate in the Champions League of one goal out of 82 corners taken”) it doesn’t always necessarily mean, however good passers of the ball they are, that a good % of corners will find the back of the net. That applies to United, too…

    I would agree that, sometimes, it does have something to do with deliveries, but perhaps 100% is too hyperbolic!!

  4. John Hannen says :

    The thing is that all set pieces require work on the training ground and that time is limited. For a club like Stoke then they’ll prioritise work on corners as corners create proportionately more of the chances they’ll have. For us though we’ll have many more free kicks around the box and more situations where we have possession of a live ball and with the need to break down a determined defence

    there just isn’t the spare time in training to devote to working on corners. If united want to put more preparation into corners then they’ll have to work less at another part of the game that provides better returns

    Professional club football is all about systems – the players are given too much credit for success and failure and this season has shown that. United have been considered to have a weaker squad than we’ve seen for a number of years but the system has meant that our results are stronger than most in Europe and we’re about to win a treble. If our corners are rubbish (and they have been for most of my 40 years to be honest) then that’s more a function of the system we have than the players we have. The system has also changed – we concede possession by design and contain in a kind of neo-cattenacio imho and people expecting us to explode into cavalier form may be disappointed with the play but I think SAF has sacrificed style for results (perhaps with half a mind on barca who will dominate possession against any team)

  5. IVOR IRWIN says :

    Nice post. It’s much simpler than anybody’s saying. Very few players are good at consistently placing corners where they want them to go. The Charlie Adam example is valid. How much is he worth? I read somewhere that S.G. Hoffenheim, who have the player in Europe with the best averages in corner kicks and dead balls in Sejad Salihović, demanded 25M quid for him when A.C. Milan started thinking of selling Andrea Pirlo to Chelsea. Of course, Salihović and Adam are not even in the same class as Pirlo, but it just goes to show how rare ‘speciality’ players are becoming. Valencia seems to be pretty good as modern wingers go. He certrainly improves Rooney’s confidence. Why English wingers like Bentley, Young, Lennon and Wright-Phillips can’t put balls into the box consistently is beyond me!

  6. rela says :

    i don’t think the problem is confined to the corner kick takers.

    goals opportunities are limited because of utd got limited players who can take advantage of balls from corner kicks.

    in fact, in utd’s starting eleven, the player who’s brilliant in the air is vidic. some players may be good with the head, e.g. chicharito, rooney (not bad i think), but they really lack the height to compete with the keeper or the defenders.

    we used to have ronaldo as an additional threat in that yard box.

    notice that too, in many free kicks, utd decides to play a short ball to a closer player instead of driving it into box.

  7. isnoor says :

    my thought on manutd not scoring from corner-kick was that we lack players who are capable of scoring with header. If you look at manutd players in the 18box of opponent during corner who can be a threat are vidic and chicharito. Rooney prefer to take the losed ball. While the rest are there to try their luck.
    I agreed with the idea that clubs are training on defending corner-kicks and yes the analysis proof it. But players with a good header are scarce.
    What a good finding by THE GAFFER

  8. Douglas Crockett says :

    As Ray Wilkins commented yesterday, in the “modern game” it’s a given that defenders can drape themselves all over offensive players on corners without a foul being called.

  9. Guest says :

    We’ve missed the formidable duo attack of Rio and Vidic both approaching the crosses together as either one or the other has been out sidelined or rested.

  10. united101 says :

    Regarding Barca’s failure to convert corners, they usually take short corners, passing the ball to another player and then crossing the ball into the box. They found success doing that in the La liga over the years.

  11. bionic eye sound says :

    Light is transmitted in the form of photons which vibrate at different frequencies.

    The photodiodes mimic the retinal cells by
    converting light into electrical signals, which are then transmitted by cells in the inner retina via nerve
    pulses to the brain. The Parviz lens is not the only attempt to unbundle technology.

  12. dog training says :

    you’re actually a excellent webmaster. The website loading pace is amazing.
    It kind of feels that you are doing any distinctive trick.
    Moreover, The contents are masterpiece. you’ve performed a fantastic activity in this subject!

  13. google advanced search engine says :

    The pyramid is a lot larger at the bottom, so there’s room for a lot the best way to, but at the pinnacle there exists only room for one.
    Mega sites, alternatively, are great for Ad – Sense.
    But, its too soon in summary between Facebook and Google+.

  14. sex tambayan says :

    I believe everything published was actually very logical.
    But, what about this? suppose you added a little content?
    I mean, I don’t wish to tell you how to run your blog,
    however suppose you added a title to maybe get people’s attention? I mean Manchester United are finding that corner kicks are delivering discouraging returns
    | ManUtd24 is kinda boring. You could peek at Yahoo’s front page and watch how they create news headlines
    to grab people to open the links. You might add a related video
    or a picture or two to get people interested about everything’ve
    written. In my opinion, it might bring your website a little bit more interesting.

  15. says :

    Excellent post! We will be linking to this particularly great content on our
    website. Keep up the great writing.

  16. wot gold giveaway july 2015 says :

    I constantly spent my half an hour to read this website’s articles all the time along with a mug of coffee.

  17. says :

    Recenntly Apple released the newest version of their
    etremely popular i – Phone line, the Apple i – Phone 4 This new
    revolutionary handset offers a slew of enhanced features that make this device tthe best
    Smartphone on the market today. I love that Parker still hears my voice, and hearing him respond maakes me feel closer to home.

    This is a great neww feature that many business travellers will welcome with opern arms.

  18. Hayley says :

    I pay a quick visit day-to-day some sites and websites to read articles or reviews, except this
    weblog presents feature based posts.

  19. Lloyd says :

    You actually make it seem so easy with your presentation butt I find this topic too be actually somethingg that
    I think I would never understand. It seems too complicated and
    extremely broad for me. I am looking forward for your
    next post, I’ll try to get the hang of it!

  20. Thelma says :

    I read this piece of writing completely about the comparison of newest andd previous technologies, it’s remarkable article.

  21. Finley says :

    Howdy just wanted to give you a quick heads up.

    The text in your post seeem to be running off the screen in Internet explorer.
    I’m not sure if this is a formatting issue or something tto
    do with browser compatibility but I figured I’d post to let yyou
    know. The layout look great though! Hope you get the problem solved soon. Thanks

  22. Simon says :

    I do noot even know how I finished up here, however I assumed
    this put up waas oonce good. I don’t understand who you’re however
    definitely you aree going to a famohs blogger in tthe event you aren’t already.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: