Analysis and Observations: Berbatov’s instincts earn United victory

Manchester Utd 1-0 Bolton: Analysis, Observations

It’s become something of a well-worn cliché, but they say that the true sign of a title-winning team is not just their ability to win games that they have dominated throughout, but to win those that they didn’t necessarily deserve either. On 18 different occasions, that has certainly rang true and proved decisive in Manchester United’s case every time they have won the League.

Here, at Old Trafford, we see it again. This hard-thought 1-0 victory over a stubborn Bolton Wanderers isn’t a game that is worth remembering for the football on display, rather what the result represents for United’s championship with rivals Arsenal dropping points on the same day.

Carrick and Rooney impress again. Both Michael Carrick and Wayne Rooney have had their fair share of criticisms this season, but both continued their run of great form of late with an assured performance worthy of most of the superlatives in the book. Carrick’s contribution mustn’t be undervalued – as his shift defensively was crucial. Especially, when the Red Devils went ten men down.

Wayne Rooney is thriving as a trequartista. He started off playing just behind Javier Hernandez and although is strike partner did not quite enjoy as much success; Rooney was a danger for the duration of this. Especially in the first half hour when his teammates looked a touch sluggish and out of sorts. He played well in this position against both Marseille and Arsenal in previous games, but it is difficult to imagine how long he’ll play there. However, with the return of Antonio Valencia, we might just see the rebirth of the 4-2-3-1, a formation which Rooney has found much enjoyment in the past, and so he may continue to play in this position. Still, it must be noted slightly higher up the pitch.

Jonny Evans – the good.

<Figure 1> As the chalkboard above shows, Evans was excellent defensively and consistently won duels in the air and stifled any threat from Bolton. In the absence of United’s ‘no-nonsense’ centre-backs Ferdinand and Vidic, he put in a decent shift and could have reflected on a good day’s work had that moment of madness not happened.

From Guardian Chalkboards

Jonny Evans – the not so good. Then there was his challenge on Stuart Holden. It was a straight red, no doubt, and he will now miss the next three games. With all the defensive problems facing Manchester United (Wes Brown also went off injured), it is perhaps a tad surprising to say this but the international break could not have come at a better time.

Bolton started daringly. The visitors were positive in their play, and had United on the backfoot in the first 45 which brought about the two changes at half time which included the scorer of the eventual winner Dimitar Berbatov. The result is pleasing; Bolton, worthy of a top table finish, are no longer pushovers and the days of beating them 4-0 are long over. Yet, the overall performance was concerning. United lacked cutting edge against a battling side who probably did deserve a 0-0. When the hosts finally cranked it up, they defended as if they had riot shields and batons. Credit to them where it’s due

The Report Card. Behaviour is no issue in this grading system, so Evans’ red has no implications on his resulting mark. Indeed, the grades are made solely out of observation of their performances.

Van der Sar C; Wes Brown C, Chris Smalling C, Jonny Evans B, Patrice Evra C; Antonio Valencia D, Michael Carrick B, Ryan Giggs C, Nani D; Wayne Rooney B+; Javier Hernandez C


4 responses to “Analysis and Observations: Berbatov’s instincts earn United victory”

  1. sem. Tonny Bbaale says :

    much as the red devils are undergoing defence problems. many teams are bound to cry. time will proove this. Go united, gooooooooooooooooo

  2. jonssonmufc says :

    Yes, it’s funny how two of our best players this season, Rooney and Carrick, also are probably the top two of the Utd players who get the most criticism from their own fans.

  3. kosio says :

    I actually though this was one of the bad games of Rooney as of late. I had the impression throughout the game that he was giving away the ball way to much(while we had 11 men). This is now confirmed by the chalkboards (20 out of 63) as compared to 11 out of 45 against liverpool and 5 out of 40 against cheski, which were two games where we were pressed much more and in theory it must have been harder to find a pass.

    The one part in his game i liked was his shooting, but as connection to his partners he did not provide enough.

    As for the red card I was very upset to see that Smalling’s 3 times failure to clear the ball lead to putting Evans into a weird 1 on 1 situation as a last man

    Generally poor game on our side, but fortunately we got a result

  4. The Gaffer says :

    jonsson: Yep, it’s funny that. Rooney less so because his ‘newer’ role is being understood more; although the imprssion I’m getting is that Carrick needs some time to get the recognition that, I think, he deserves.

    Kosio: I’ve looked at said chalkboards and while about a third of his passes went astray, it is important to note where those successful passes went; most of them forward or to wingers in the ‘trequartista’ position and he seems to be fulfilling that role quite well.

    Yes, bit disappointed with Smalling’s performance yesterday and perhaps didn’t see that coming considering his form of late.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: