Analysis and Observations: Fergie makes up for his meddling

Southampton 1-2 Manchester United: Observations

Michael Owen celebrates scoring for Manchester United

Manchester United were hardly at their scintillating best at St Mary’s in this rather contained affair, but then again they hardly have to be to end victorious. There’s a running theme through United’s season where they don’t need to play particularly good to win a game, they just don’t need to play bad either. Southampton were valiant, and had controlled the game for a good hour or so, but United finally got a grasp on the game when United shuffled around and made changes; not just in personnel but in shape, too.

United’s diamond had no shine. Sir Alex held his hands up for United’s ineffective showing telling MUTV after the game: “Sometimes we make it difficult for ourselves but, in fairness, I maybe meddled with the system somewhat this afternoon.” And, in truth, United really did make it difficult for themselves. Their system hardly allowed any room for creativity – Gibson and Anderson took turns to drift left and Michael Owen dropped uncharacteristically deep. Heck, at times, Gabriel Obertan played in that second striker role. While some (wrongly) dubbed him the ‘New Thierry Henry’ before he joined the club in 2009, he is much accustomed to the wide role and that showed in the second half where, in a standard 4-4-2, he made the assist for the Owen goal on the right hand side.

Fergie continued and admitted his trial with the diamond formation hardly paid dividends: “We tried a diamond in the middle of the pitch and, of course, Manchester United are used to playing with width all the time and I think that was a problem for us. It wasn’t working at all. We had some possession of the ball but we never really threatened.”

Selection was fine, to an extent. United’s selection hardly surprised anyone. It didn’t – it had all the usual suspects of the rotation system; Darron Gibson (who played badly but cut him some slack), Chris Smalling  etc and even a debut for Anders Lindegaard. But Southampton have the qualities of a top Championship side (should have been promoted last season, if not for a handicap of being docked 10 points) rather than that of a team in the third tier of English football and so they certainly sensed a chance to actually win the game. United have incredible strength in depth, but as shown from the defeat against West Ham that wholesale changes aren’t necessarily the answer.

Southampton, led by Ricky Lambert, Chamberlain and goalscorer Chaplow, proved to be a stern test. But when Fergie made changes, inevitably United improved. On came Ryan Giggs and Nani, off went the lacklustre Gibson and Anderson. United settled and started to dominate, and soon they took charge; Owen headed home in the 65th minute and Hernandez, collecting a Giggs pass, sealed it ten minutes later. Sir Alex did make up for his meddling, thankfully, with those changes.

Jonny Evans and Wes Brown impress. “Eh? You serious.” I am. In fact, this has hardly been a season to savour for the Irishman or, indeed, Brown. One of them has been crippled by injuries and the other a prolonged run of bad form. But Evans was solid and assured for 90 minutes (like he was in the 3rd round against Liverpool) and Brown, coming on as a second half sub, got used to surroundings. It may be the start of something better for those two…


4 responses to “Analysis and Observations: Fergie makes up for his meddling”

  1. Sleepy Nik says :

    Some good stuff as usual mate. Particularly the point on Evans/Brown; I have long maintained that we have had the best defensive unit in Europe with the likes of Rio, Vidic, Brown, Evans, Smalling, and the da Silva’s to call upon. Evans will come good, and Fergie really should be making more of an effort to make amends with Brown, who has been a fantastic servant to the club despite injuries, and arguably the leagues finest ‘natural defender’ – to quote the great man himself.

  2. ZnakeY says :

    I agree Brown and in part Evans looked good, but I only wish the later and Fabio got a chance with the other first choice back four, Evans is much better when playing alongside Rio, maybe part of why his season has gone as it has.

  3. The Gaffer says :

    Cheers for the comments:

    Nik: Agreed; Brown is perhaps the best natural defender in England thanks to his physical nature, awareness and strengths in the air, not to mention his versatility.

    It’s all gone a bit pear-shaped since a broken metatarsal against Wolves on 6th March in his final appearance of the last campaign and since then, he’s hardly been able to muster more than 60 minutes. He’s coming back now though…and won’t be surprised if he gets the nod at right back against Villa in midweek (still think he’s a tad better than Rafael).

    Brown and Sir might have made up. There were reports in the summer after the story emerged that Brown is a certainty to be going in January – and that won’t happen, as we know. It seems, maybe, that he is still part of Fergie’s plans.

    ZnakeY: I can’t disagree – but still think it’s more than just partnering Ferdinand. After that dismal performance against West Ham where we lost 4-0, he was dropped for the next however many games and given a brief spell with the reserves. Since then, he’s certainly come of age and was solid against Liverpool in the previous round, and again here at St Mary’s.

    He does need games, I agree.

  4. Written Offside says :

    Good stuff as usual

    Fabio looked good in first half and seems to be a bit more controlled than his brother in his moves up and down the flank. Agree that Evans was pretty solid.

    Impressed by Lindegaard although he did not have loads to do – comfortable with the ball at his feet and sound distribution always good to see.

    Not convinced by Obertan and Gibson at the moment – they need games but when they play they struggle to impress – vicious circle!

    Tough game on Tuesday but can see a tight victory

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: